2023 – Mackenzie Kuiken (photos)

2022 – Kate Dixon (photos)

2021 – Novalee Lewis (photos)

2020 – Marianne Bautista (Miss Congeniality) (photos)

2019 – Lily Lloyd (photos)

2018 – Summer Keffeler (photos)

2017 – Alyssa Williams (photos)

2016 – Claire Wright (photos)

2015 – Priya Gopal-Walker (photos)

2014 – Starla Sampaco (photos)

2013 – Imani Blackmon

2012 – Alex Carlson-Helo

2011 – Cheyenne Van Tine

2010 – Camilla Cyr (Semi-Finalist)

2009 – Sadie Porter (Semi-Finalist)

2008 – Mandy Schendel

2007 – Shalane Larango

2006 – Kendra Timm

2005 – Kaylee Moore

2004 – Danielle Jensen

2003 – Jasmine Colleen Jorgenson (Semi-Finalist)

2002 – Maichal McJunkin

2001 – Shannon Hulbert (Semi-Finalist)

2000 – Megan Munroe (Semi-Finalist)

1999 – Dianna Carlson

1998 – Amber Lancaster

1997 – Emma Louise DeSillets

1996 – Emily Ballard

1995 – Summer Springer

1994 – Angelie Eldred (Miss Photogenic)

1993 – Rebecca Vaughn

1992 – Kaylee O’Kelley

1991 – Elizabeth Lee

1990 – Paige Anderson

1989 – Amy Travis (Semi-Finalist)

1988 – Karen Petre

1987 – Johna Sainsbury

1986 – Lisa Elliot

1985 – Drew Holmer (2nd runner up)

1984 – Charlene Walters

1983 – Rhonda Monroe (Semi-Finalist)